A directory can lose its independence in small steps: a paid exception, an undisclosed relationship, a shortcut in review, or an old listing left to look current. Publishing a policy does not prevent those failures. It gives readers specific behavior to check.
The entry bar changes quietly
A directory may loosen its criteria to increase the number of listings. Compare the published entry bar with the entries you can see. A claim that every business has been reviewed needs evidence on the listing, rather than a general assurance elsewhere.
Inclusion becomes something to buy
A paid fast lane, a promoted position or a commercial relationship influencing acceptance would conflict with our funding policy. The paid-placement policy explains that commitment without pretending software makes a breach impossible.
Ownership goes undisclosed
A publisher-owned property may be listed, but the relationship must be prominent and the same criteria must apply. An undisclosed relationship, invented independent endorsement or preferential selection is the failure.
Descriptions become promotional claims
A description should explain what a business offers. Unsupported superlatives, fabricated results and unqualified claims of quality make it harder for a reader to judge the business on its own terms.
The boundaries are set out in the Line.
Old information looks current
The current site does not automatically enforce a review log or expiry interval. Editors must act on outdated listings and must not change a review date simply because a page was republished.
If a destination changes or a business appears to close, one failed connection is not enough to establish closure. The method explains the intended review process. Removal requests are a separate privacy matter and need not produce a public announcement.
Empty pages multiply
Category and location pages are not useful merely because they exist. Our editorial standard requires enough qualifying entries and a useful introduction. That is a review responsibility, rather than a claim about an automatic publication gate.
Report the mismatch
Send the URL, the relevant claim and what you observed through corrections. A public policy that no longer matches the site needs correction too.
Our entry bar in full and how directories make money explain the underlying choices. Use the visible behavior to judge whether those choices are still being followed.
